Market demand for better quality
finish has forced both the tube producers and equipment suppliers to
look for a better way of annealing stainless steel tube.
Induction
heating is now the accepted technology for any high speed
processing line.
Radyne specializes in designing both dull and bright annealing
systems for a wide variety of parts from engine parts to hand tools to
wire and tube.
Bright and dull annealing of stainless steel wire, rod and
tube is not a new subject, what is new is the change in technology to
achieve the desired result. Most installations in the past
used off-line annealing facilities because the technology for a compact
installation in-line with the tube mill and welder did not
exist. For bright annealing it was a conveyorised furnace
using cracked ammonia for the process atmosphere and nitrogen for
purging, later bottled or bulk hydrogen proved to be a better
alternative as it removed the ever present problem of residual ammonia
in the annealing atmosphere.
For dull annealing batch furnaces many gas fired were used and still
are, quenching is by batch followed by pickling of the tubes to remove
the surface oxide and improve the surface finish.
Market demand for better quality finish has forced both the tube
manufacturers and equipment manufacturers to look for a better way of
annealing tube. Most of the production is in the austenitic
grades although some duplex steels and ferritic steels are annealed but
the volume is quite small compared to the austenitic grades in the 300
series.
Of course the other important factor is competition in the stainless
steel tube market globally which has brought to many manufacturers the
reality their existing plant is inadequate technically and commercially
Induction heating technology is now accepted as the technology
of choice for any high speed processing line or lines requiring compact
heating combined with rapid response. Examples of this
technology adoption is hardening and tempering of carbon steel rod for
spring wire and seam and full body annealing of carbon steel tube,
quench and temper lines for pipe, steel bar and wire, copper tube
annealing, steel strip coating both metallic and organic and stainless
steel tube annealing. All of these examples have one common
denominator – they are continuous and it the use of high speed
induction heating technology that has made this possible.
METALLURGICAL
REQUIREMENTS
Austenitic stainless steels are not hardenable but like most metals
suffer from work hardening both during the manufacture of the tube and
during later processes. Annealing which is also sometimes
referred to as solution heat treatment not only recrystallises the
structure but dissolves carbides back into the austenite.
Annealing temperatures range from 1050oC to 1150oC although temperature
can be altered according to the time at temperature and with induction
heating this can be closely controlled. Time at temperature
is not a critical issue, it can be too short and where the annealing is
in-line this has to be carefully considered as there is a direct
correlation between time and machine length.
In the case of dull annealing the time at temperature should be
minimised to keep surface oxide formation to a minimum, with induction
heating this is rarely a problem as the time at annealing temperature
is measured in seconds before direct water quenching.
Bright annealing requires the use of a highly reducing gas atmosphere,
hydrogen being the commonly used gas.
A further consideration of in-line tube annealing is the weld zone of
the tube which is a continuous seam and becomes ferritic as a result of
the welding process. It can be physically detected because of its
response to a magnetic field.
As part of any in-line annealing process, it is essential the tube
surface is cleaned thoroughly to ensure it is free of any grease, oil
or other carbonaceous material before it enters the annealing
system. Such residues will lead to surface carburisation and
impair the corrosion resistance of the steel.
The annealing process also requires the quenching be rapid,
particularly through the upper critical range to minimise carbide
precipitation, with dull annealing this is not a problem but with
bright annealing it must be carried out under the protective gas
atmosphere which means the quench is indirect and slower.
PRACTICAL LIMITATIONS
Heating
For specific markets and applications the use of a quartz tube in the
heating coil isolates the hydrogen gas atmosphere from the induction
coil and creates a gas tight chamber, but at the same time is
transparent to the induced currents from the heating coil.
The down side to this approach is the size of the quartz tube relative
to the product being heated and the resultant induction heating coil
size which lowers the heating efficiency.
The alternative approach is a gas tight induction heating coil but it
requires considerable care in manufacture with precision sealing of the
enclosure and is generally more costly to produce than the quartz tube
approach. It does however deliver a higher heating efficiency.
Quenching
In many if not all installations where the annealing is in-line with
the drawing equipment or tube the mill it is not the
heating that is the challenge, it is the quench. Where direct
quenching using say water as the quenching medium is used for dull
annealing there is no problem, however when an indirect quench has to
be used such as with bright annealing of stainless steel because of the
protective gas atmosphere the rate of heat transfer becomes a critical
design element. The impact of indirect quenching is reflected
in the overall length of the machine and can in some circumstances
where space is limited, prevent the adoption of in-line bright
annealing.
Gas
System
For bright annealing systems there is one further limitation and that
is the protective atmosphere gas required for the bright
finish. The tube when annealed passes through a sealed
system, so, providing the welding process is sound, mechanical seals at
the entry and exit prevent contamination of the hydrogen gas
atmosphere. This is important for a number of reasons:
First and foremost is safety, any entry of oxygen into the system and
mixing with the hydrogen can create a hazardous situation.
Second, contamination can affect the surface finish of the tube but
this is only on the outside of the tube.
For tubulars the inside surface of the tube is not exposed to the
hydrogen atmosphere and must rely on a constant stream of argon
gas to minimise oxidation not only during welding but through
the heating and quenching phases of the annealing process.
The practical limitation here is the volume of gas required to fill the
tube which is open to the atmosphere at both ends of the mill line.
This limitation sets the upper diameter of tube that is practical to
bright anneal in-line with the mill.
DULL
ANNEALING SYSTEMS
This is often the stepping stone from off line annealing
to in line annealing, it is compact requiring a standard induction
heating system followed by a dwell zone and then a direct water
quench.
Obviously the tube still needs to be pickled after annealing, but the
benefits of using induction heating are:
1. The quantity of scale formed is very
small and this results directly from the very short heating time, in
many cases it is so light as to be considered simply a change in colour.
2. Pickling time is reduced resulting in
higher productivity on a daily basis.
3. Acid useage is reduced as a direct
result of reducing the oxide layer on the tube.
4. Tube distortion is minimised. The tube
can be sized in line before it is cut to length thus enhancing the
quality of tube produced.
5. Electrical energy is reduced when
compared to the use of an electric resistance type furnace. If gas is
the energy source for the annealing furnace other considerations must
be taken into account such as:
5.1. Maintenance of refractories.
5.2. Furnace start-up time.
5.3. Furnace idle time.
6. Work in progress is reduced.
7. Orders can be progressed faster and
small orders filled more economically. (Subject to mill change over).
8. Can be integrated into an existing
line. A typical system for tube up to 80mm diameter and subject to line
speed has a line foot print of approx 2 metres x 1metre plus the power
supply and ancillary equipment.
9. The existing batch or conveyor type
annealing furnace can be scrapped and the floor space released for
other uses.
10. Costs associated with removal of
spent acid and licences to discharge effluent into sewerage systems are
eliminated.
EQUIPMENT
Heating
The induction heating system comprises three major items:
1. a power supply
2. an induction heating coil and
interconnecting busbar
3. a closed loop water cooling system for
the power electronics.
Radyne power supplies for this type of application are solid state IGBT
type having a series output circuit and variable ratio output isolation
transformer for load impedance matching. The duty cycle is
continuous and input power factor is 0.95 under all operating
conditions.
One of the important requirements of a continuous line application is
the accuracy of the output power regulation, the Radyne power supply
has an output regulation accuracy of +/-1% of rated power with +/-10%
line variance to ensure precise process control.
Since the wall thickness of most stainless steel tube up to 80mm
diameter ranges from less than 1mm up to 3mm (this is the volume
production), the frequency of the output is 30kHZ which delivers an
excellent operational efficiency for the various combinations of wall
thickness to outside diameter. The other consideration in
selecting this frequency is the current carrying capacity of the IGBT’s
is more conservative than at higher frequencies of 50kHZ.
At these frequencies the busbar length should be kept short to minimise
power losses which means the power supply is close to the line and
leads to a very compact installation.
Induction heating coils are made to suit each application but follow a
standard design and manufacturing criteria, with dull annealing
installations the coil coupling to the tube size range can be kept
tight and hence the coil heating efficiency will be high. An
important point to keep in mind with any induction heating application
is the response of the power system to a load that is non magnetic ie
materials such as copper, brass, aluminium and austenitic stainless
steel to name the most common. Ferrous steel up to 720oC or
what is called “curie” is magnetic and will heat quickly with very high
coil efficiencies. Beyond this temperature it becomes non magnetic and
responds similarly to the materials mentioned above with the result
that the induced current must be higher to compensate for the lower
coil efficiency. It is difficult to generalize on this point
because of the many variables that affect the coil heating efficiency,
but for a stainless steel tube mid range diameter say 50mm and wall of
2mm a coil efficiency of 68% is realistic.
Since the operating temperature is in the range 1050oC to 1100oC it is
essential the inside of the coil be lined with refractory to reduce the
radiant and conducted heat reaching the water cooled coil
turns. This is one of the factors limiting how tight the
induction coil can be wound for a particular application, the other is
the range of tube
sizes that one coil can accommodate and this is dictated by the power
supply and the ability to deliver the required power to a small tube in
a relatively large coil.
Quench
For dull annealing the quench comprises a high volume discharge ring
through which the tube passes and all is contained in a tank with the
recirculating pump.
After leaving the quench the tube can be sized and cut to length ready
for pickling.
Exit
end of the induction coil and direct water quench for the Dull
Annealing system.
BRIGHT
ANNEALING SYSTEM
These systems are by far creating the most interest in the market place
primarily because they facilitate the production of better finish on
the tube surface at much lower cost. Bright annealing of cut lengths of
tube has been around for a long time using conveyor type furnaces and
continuous in-line systems have been used by some manufacturers for ten
years or more because they recognised the benefits would outweigh the
costs.
In the last decade developments have taken place in the power supplies
bringing to the line higher frequencies with higher operating
efficiencies and the quench system technology has improved and will
continue to improve with new materials and techniques.
The benefits of a bright in-line system are:
1. Wire, Rod, and Tube leaves the
annealer with a bright outside surface requiring no further finishing.
2. Distortion is minimised. The wire, rod
and tube is sized in line before it is cut to length thus enhancing the
quality of tube produced.
3. Electrical energy is reduced when
compared to the use of an electric resistance type furnace. If gas is
the energy source for the annealing furnace other considerations must
be taken into account:
3.1.
Maintenance of refractories.
3.2.
Maintenance of muffles or radiant tubes to contain the furnace
atmosphere.
3.3.
Maintenance of heating elements and connections.
3.4. Cost
of furnace start-up time.
3.5. Cost
of furnace idle time.
4. Work in progress is reduced.
5. Orders can be progressed faster and
small orders filled more economically. (Subject to mill change over).
6. Can be integrated into an existing
line. A typical system for tube up to 80mm diameter and subject to line
speed has a line foot print of approx 6 metres x 0.75 metre plus the
power supply and ancillary equipment which is usually mounted to one
side.
7. The existing batch or conveyor type
annealing furnace can be scrapped and the floor space released for
other uses.
8. Water cooling systems are not
contaminated with scale thus maintenance costs are lowered.
9. Labor costs are usually lower as the
need to move bundles of tube from one processing cell to another are
eliminated.
Bright
Annealing System
EQUIPMENT
Heating
The induction heating system for bright annealing is similar to that
required for dull annealing in that the major components are the same
but there the similarity ends.

The power supply is identical for both bright and dull annealing. Only
the induction coil matching changes.
Earlier designs of the induction heating coil were sized to allow for a
quartz tube to be inserted that isolated the refractory lined induction
coil from the product passing through the centre of the quartz tube.
The latest design utilizes an economical solution of a gas tight
chamber providing an environment for annealing that is:
1. Impervious gas leakage at elevated
temperatures.
2. It is not porous.
3. It can be readily sealed to the entry
vestibule and dwell chambers by mechanical seals with expansion
compensation.
4. It does not deteriorate with constant
use.
From the heating coil the product tube passes through a dwell zone
which is unheated but allows the recrystallization to complete and
chromium carbides to be taken back into solution.
Quench
From the dwell zone the product tube passes into the indirect gas
quench which is an externally water cooled heat exchanger and uses
solid carbon as the transfer medium from the product tube to
the water to reduce the temperature from 1050oC to 120oC at exit. Each
product size requires a change in the carbon blocks to achieve optimum
cooling rates and this necessitates making space available at the exit
end of the line to make the change with a minimum of inconvenience. A
direct water quench is placed between the annealer and the sizing rolls
to remove all heat from the product before it enters the sizing rolls.
The quench is modular in construction and allows for easy removal of
sections for maintenance, the design also allows for easy thread up and
system sealing.
Gas
System
To achieve a bright surface finish on the stainless steel during the
annealing process requires a gas that is highly reducing. Hydrogen is
the gas of choice. The down side to this is that when combined with
oxygen in the form of air in the right proportions it is
explosive. To overcome this an inert gas is used for purging
and safety, the commercially available gases for this duty are nitrogen
and argon and it is really a choice for the user based on cost and
convenience. Most stainless steel tube plants have argon
available for the tube welding process so it makes sense to use argon
for purging and safety. Very few plants today use gas
generators such as the ammonia dissociator combined with gas dryers to
service bright annealing, most use bottled gas.
1. It is more convenient.
2. Gas generators and dryers are costly
to purchase and maintain.
3. Induction annealing systems use very
little gas provided the seals are maintained in good order.
It is important to note that the annealer must be completely sealed
before hydrogen gas is introduced and this means the product tube must
be passed through the annealer until it reaches the sizing
rolls. At this point all seals are locked in place and the
line started, when the welded tube exits the last seal of the quench
chamber the operator starts the annealer. Inert gas is
admitted to the system at a predetermined flow rate, the procedure is
automatic from the time the operator initiates the start and cannot for
safety reasons alter the purging times. Once hydrogen is
admitted and the annealer cleared of the purge gas power is brought on
to the induction heating coil and annealing proceeds.
The bright annealing system using induction heating technology offers
any stainless steel wire, rod or tube manufacturer the opportunity of
incorporating it into existing lines or specifying it for new
lines. One has only to look at the development of high speed
copper tube annealing lines by Radyne to see where it can go. These
lines now operate at speeds up to 2000 ft./minute / 600 metres /minute.